Romina Massa's Blog

3 Data-Backed Reasons Why Social Media Comments Matter More Than You Think

Written by Romina Massa | Feb 24, 2025 12:28:27 PM

The Overlooked Power of Social Media Comments

Numbers don’t lie, and people trust people. Social media platforms thrive on engagement—but not all engagement is created equal. While likes are great and shares are crucial, comments carry their own unique weight in how algorithms determine content visibility.

Comments are one of the most valuable forms of engagement because they signal meaningful interaction. The more comments a post receives, the more it is pushed into other users’ feeds, extending its reach far beyond its immediate audience. Now, think of a post with so many comments it gets seen everywhere, and your engaging comment at the top of the thread. 

Why should marketers, content creators, and brands focus more on social media comments? Here are three data-backed reasons why comment strategy should be a core part of your social media engagement approach.

1. Social Media Comments Directly Influence Algorithmic Ranking

Social media algorithms prioritize content that drives interaction. Comments rank higher than likes or simple impressions because they indicate an actual conversation, which platforms like LinkedIn, Instagram, and Facebook interpret as a sign of valuable content.

⚡ Why this matters: Posts with more comments are given higher feed ranking, meaning they stay visible longer and are pushed to more users. Fostering discussions is a must if you want your content to be seen.

⚡ How to leverage this: End your posts with questions, strong calls to action (CTAs), or discussion prompts that encourage people to comment rather than just like and scroll away. Participate actively in other's posts with comments that add value and stay relevant to your brand. 

2. Comment Engagement Can 10x Your Social Media Reach

We know that posts with significant comment engagement receive exponentially more reach than those with passive engagement.

⚡ Why this matters: A comment doesn’t just boost a post once. It re-triggers distribution every time someone adds a new one, expanding its visibility to new audiences. The more conversation in the comments, the more likely the algorithm will keep surfacing that content. Whether it's your post or a post with your comment on it, you want this to happen. 

⚡ How to leverage this: Engage. Participating proactively in relevant content can turn your comment into your most successful content of the week, and responding to every comment on your posts can multiply the engagement rate and keep the post alive longer in feeds.

3. Social Media Comments Build Trust & Community

A post with high comment engagement creates a stronger sense of community than one with passive reactions. People trust people, not faceless brands, and they are more likely to engage with authentic and interactive content. That includes your relevant comment on someone else's post. 

⚡ Why this matters: Brands that spark conversations in comment sections can see higher retention rates, increased brand trust, and deeper audience connections over time.

⚡ How to leverage this: Be present. Share thoughtful insights, add value to the discussion, ask relevant questions, reply thoughtfully, and create a space where discussions feel natural and valuable.

Key Takeaway: Your Most Valuable Social Media Content Might Not Be a Post at All

If you're only focusing on your posts, you might be ignoring your best-performing content: your comments on other people's posts. Think of the huge impact of Duolingo’s “death” announcement or Olipop seizing the moment for free when Poppi flopped after sending several $25,000 vending machines to influencers. 

⚡ A well-placed comment can outperform an entire post. Social media isn't just about broadcasting; it’s about joining conversations in ways that put you in front of the right people at the right time.

⚡ Your next viral moment might not come from a perfectly crafted post, but from a sharp, insightful comment that takes off in the right thread.

Are you treating your comments like content?